FRC’s Are CoCo Bonds Suitable as Core Capital Instruments?
Kevin Dowd

 

Basel III introduced significant innovations in bank regulation. One of them is the minimum required leverage ratio. To help banks implementing the new measure , Basel III created two different core capital measures: Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) and Additional Tier 1 (AT1). Since raising capital for CET1 is expensive, other instruments are used to build up AT1 in case of need, like for example Contingent Convertible (CoCo), which can convert to equity or written-down when a bank  is under stress. In this paper we show that CoCos are not suitable as regulatory core capital instruments. Problems of timing, incentives, systemic risk, regulatory discretion and regulatory capture make CoCos unreliable as core capital instruments (unlike other hybrid instruments), and regulators should not treat them as such.

Download the paper here.